Fundraising cancer victim turned down for vital care

Refused life-saving treatment – cancer patient Esther Edwards Refused life-saving treatment – cancer patient Esther Edwards

A CANCER fundraiser who has been refused life-saving treatment says a primary care trust is “playing God” with her life.

Esther Edwards, 68, of Raymonds Drive, Benfleet, suffers from rare neuroendocrine tumours in her liver, and has been treated at London’s Royal Free Hospital for six years.

Leading specialists have written to NHS South West Essex saying she needs special radiation treatment called radionuclide – targeted radiotherapy which would blast tumours and give her a better chance of survival.

However, the treatment costs up to £40,000 for a three-session course and the health trust says it can’t afford it.

Esther said: “The Royal Free said I needed this treatment and I had the impression there would be no problem.

“A few weeks later my doctor called to say the treatment had been refused. I couldn’t believe it. It feels like the primary care trust is playing God with my life.

“This treatment is the best one for my condition and would increase dramatically my chances of survival. I am in limbo, not knowing what is going to happen.”

Funding for the treatment is provided for patients of other primary care trusts.

Esther added: “My condition is getting worse and this radiation would help me live longer. My life is hanging in the balance.”

The great-grandmother had part of her bowel removed in 2006 and has faced monthly injections since, to keep the tumours under control.

But the size of these increased in January, prompting the need for new treatment.

Esther raises money for the NET Patient Foundation, in Castle Point, a charity which works to raise awareness of the rare cancer. Since January, she and friend, Joan Wells, have raised more than £4,000 for the campaign.

Foundation director Catherine Bouvier has written to the trust in support of Esther.

She said: “This type of cancer is very rare and leading doctors at the Royal Free have put forward a very detailed case as to why Esther needs the treatment. Other trusts pay for this treatment and the majority of patients have been supported.”

There are about 3,000 cases of neuroendocrine tumours in the UK each year.

A spokesman for NHS South West Essex confirmed it had declined a number of individual funding requests for Yttrium 90 radionuclide (as a treatment for neuroendocrine tumours) in recent months. The spokesman added: “This is due to the limited evidence of this treatment’s clinical cost-effectiveness.

“Any patient whose funding request has been declined can request the decision to be considered through the appeals process.’’

Comments (9)

11:39am Sun 8 Jul 12

SpiffSpaff84 says...

Welcome to britain, meanwhile we are increasing the money we send to other countries
Welcome to britain, meanwhile we are increasing the money we send to other countries SpiffSpaff84

11:40am Sun 8 Jul 12

SpiffSpaff84 says...

Welcome to britain, meanwhile we are increasing the money we send to other countries
Welcome to britain, meanwhile we are increasing the money we send to other countries SpiffSpaff84

1:43pm Sun 8 Jul 12

jolllyboy says...

"limited evidence of this treatment’s clinical cost-effectiveness. "
Well there always will be if patients are not allowed to have it.

Disgraceful. Good luck to her in her appeal.
"limited evidence of this treatment’s clinical cost-effectiveness. " Well there always will be if patients are not allowed to have it. Disgraceful. Good luck to her in her appeal. jolllyboy

2:19pm Sun 8 Jul 12

whataday says...

Agree with the comments above.
One thing though if she lives in Benfleet then her Primary Care Trust is NHS South EAST Essex not South West
Might be worth reapplying
Agree with the comments above. One thing though if she lives in Benfleet then her Primary Care Trust is NHS South EAST Essex not South West Might be worth reapplying whataday

6:00pm Sun 8 Jul 12

GManUSA says...

Is it any wonder we do not want National Healthcare in the USA when government functionaries make life and death decisions not doctors.

Glad to be living in the USA for many years.
Is it any wonder we do not want National Healthcare in the USA when government functionaries make life and death decisions not doctors. Glad to be living in the USA for many years. GManUSA

6:34pm Sun 8 Jul 12

arfletch says...

How much will the trust have to cough up to keep her living when she has to be admitted as an in-patient (sorry Esther?)
How much will the trust have to cough up to keep her living when she has to be admitted as an in-patient (sorry Esther?) arfletch

8:02pm Sun 8 Jul 12

soul man says...

the money spent by castle point on that stupid model or whatever on hadleigh roundabout would have more than covered the cost of this womans treatment, but no, waste money on a mickey mouse event by the castle for a few days instead
the money spent by castle point on that stupid model or whatever on hadleigh roundabout would have more than covered the cost of this womans treatment, but no, waste money on a mickey mouse event by the castle for a few days instead soul man

12:20pm Mon 9 Jul 12

BevanJ says...

Um, GManUSA - the the US you have profit-motivated INSURANCE companies making these life or death decisions about your care instead. And if Ms Edwards was one of the 50 million people in your country without insurance, she would not be receiving any treatment at all. Which explains why most Americans I know desperately want a national health service....
Um, GManUSA - the the US you have profit-motivated INSURANCE companies making these life or death decisions about your care instead. And if Ms Edwards was one of the 50 million people in your country without insurance, she would not be receiving any treatment at all. Which explains why most Americans I know desperately want a national health service.... BevanJ

4:11pm Mon 9 Jul 12

maywood says...

Suppose I am going to get backlash for this comment. If this lady was a member of Royalty,how long do you think she would have to wait ?.
Suppose I am going to get backlash for this comment. If this lady was a member of Royalty,how long do you think she would have to wait ?. maywood

Comments are closed on this article.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree