- Mobile site
- E-Newsletters
-
- News feed
- Find us on Twitter
@Essex_Echo
Follow us
- Find us on Facebook
Echo
Like us on Facebook
Cyclist to sue after ‘shared space’ fall on Southend seafront (From Echo)
Get involved: send your pictures, video, news and views by texting ECHONEWS to 80360, or email us »
Cyclist to sue after ‘shared space’ fall on Southend seafront
10:00am Wednesday 29th August 2012 in News
A FURIOUS cyclist is suing Southend Council after dislocating her ankle in the town’s seafront “shared space” zone.
Visitor Karen Stanley, 51, came to the town with her husband, Neil, 43, for a bike ride along the seafront, including the revamped £7.6million City Beach area, in Marine Parade.
Spotting three cars behind her, she pulled over to let them through, tripping over the small kerb which runs through the zone.
Mrs Stanley now faces six weeks in plaster and has had to cancel a holiday in Menorca, because of the August 18 accident.
She said: “We will be putting in a personal injury claim against the council, but we will also be appealing for more signs and road markings to help define the boundaries.
“We feel this whole shared space concept the council loves is very confusing and, with five different-coloured stone blocks and the road surface, it’s very difficult to know what is flush with the pathway or where the kerbs are.”
In the shared space zone, pedestrians, drivers and cyclists are supposed to mix freely. The scheme was a cornerstone of the council’s bid for Government funding to revamp the seafront, which was finally finished in March last year.
However, many users say the area’s layout is confusing and potentially dangerous.
The kerbs in some parts of the zone have a visible step up from the road, while others have a smooth slope into the pavement.
The Echo launched a campaign for changes last summer, after two children were knocked down in Marine Parade in the space of six weeks.
Mrs Stanley, who lives in Brentwood, said it was hard for outsiders to work out who had priority. She added: “I just didn’t realise the kerb was there.
“Thankfully, we both wear helmets and the police were nearby and able to call the ambulance quickly.”
Zulfi Ali, the council’s strategic highways and traffic manager, said: “We are very sorry to hear about this incident.
“Independent reviews have shown the area meets the necessary safety standards.
“However, as part of our road safety initiatives, we continue to monitor all our transportation networks across the borough.”
Comments are closed on this article.
Comments (74)
10:13am Wed 29 Aug 12
Blind Haze says...
10:38am Wed 29 Aug 12
Richy don't shine shoes no more says...
10:42am Wed 29 Aug 12
PJR-121 says...
10:49am Wed 29 Aug 12
Rayleigh_boy says...
10:57am Wed 29 Aug 12
perini says...
10:59am Wed 29 Aug 12
Eastwood Biker says...
11:03am Wed 29 Aug 12
BD says...
As for this woman - open your eyes! There's not actually anything to suggest it is a shared space (other than the councils misleading signs!) and legally its not a shared space and should be treated as a road, which everyone else has managed to do quite successfully...
11:06am Wed 29 Aug 12
BD says...
and as forthis woman hopefully the judge will tell her to stop wasting time and open her eyes. Yes the road is tight but you shouldnt be slowing down to let cars past, and legally its not shared space so should be treated as a normal road, which have kerbs!"
11:06am Wed 29 Aug 12
BD says...
11:12am Wed 29 Aug 12
PJR-121 says...
11:20am Wed 29 Aug 12
AnotherSister says...
11:27am Wed 29 Aug 12
reptile says...
11:58am Wed 29 Aug 12
...???... says...
Of course not. I would like to know if the council ever pays out for this though, if they do i may well put in a claim everytime i have to step up a kerb as that kerb has meant me using more energy, someone obviously has to pay for my extra time and effort, i mean, if everywhere was flat i could get around much easier!!!!!
12:02pm Wed 29 Aug 12
V_is_back says...
Secondly I agree the colour of the paving makes it difficult to see the kerbs. It is as if they are deliberately camouflaged. One part of the area has a six inch step which is all but invisible until it trips you. Here's a picture of that step I saw somewhere else: http://bit.ly/NW5rNu
The first mistake made was when Mrs Stanley 'pulled over to let cars pass'. I was under the impression this was a 20mph zone which is shared equally between pedestrians, cyclists, and motor vehicles. Why was she pulling over?
I hope she does sue Southend council and wins. Perhaps then Southend council will wake up and realise their seafront is not safe for all users at all.
12:06pm Wed 29 Aug 12
Max 269 says...
12:12pm Wed 29 Aug 12
V_is_back says...
Helmets don't work, as evidenced by her dislocated ankle.
12:13pm Wed 29 Aug 12
r6keith says...
12:16pm Wed 29 Aug 12
V_is_back says...
It is my understanding that no cycling or pedestrian groups were consulted by SBC over the design and layout of Marine Parade or of the seafront cycle routes.
Now they are reaping the results of that failure to consult.
12:17pm Wed 29 Aug 12
Dangerous driver says...
12:43pm Wed 29 Aug 12
DCLEIGH says...
12:45pm Wed 29 Aug 12
DCLEIGH says...
She said she was satisfied (not sure if it was with the amount awarded or because of the new found pleasure of cycling with the saddle the wrong way up !)
12:47pm Wed 29 Aug 12
Tom from Southend says...
12:48pm Wed 29 Aug 12
Alice in Her Own Land :P says...
12:49pm Wed 29 Aug 12
Alice in Her Own Land :P says...
12:51pm Wed 29 Aug 12
V_is_back says...
1:15pm Wed 29 Aug 12
rjsizzler says...
1:21pm Wed 29 Aug 12
V_is_back says...
The best solution, because the road there is too narrow for cars to safely pass cyclists, is to ride far enough out so that cars can't try to squeeze past. That is the advice given by the Institute of Advanced Motorists.
1:30pm Wed 29 Aug 12
Eric Whim says...
1:35pm Wed 29 Aug 12
j-w says...
2:37pm Wed 29 Aug 12
Max Impact says...
2:48pm Wed 29 Aug 12
Nebs says...
3:14pm Wed 29 Aug 12
SoTyred says...
But would I sue if I hit a kerb when cycling there? No, of course not.
In any case, far more dangerous are the idiots who get out of their cars, step into the cycling lane or simply just stand in it in the area between Three Shells Beach and the casino. I have lost count how many times I have nearly hit someone. And if I do, I assume it would be me who ends up getting sued.
3:37pm Wed 29 Aug 12
Keptquiettillnow says...
4:04pm Wed 29 Aug 12
rjsizzler says...
The aim appears to be to make people drive slowly through the lack of obvious division between road and pavement. But problems seem to arise when pedestians become confused as they aren't used to paying attention.
4:17pm Wed 29 Aug 12
V_is_back says...
Here's an example in Auckland which shows how shared spaces are supposed to work.
http://youtu.be/OcyZ
Ay8DPb0
4:26pm Wed 29 Aug 12
V_is_back says...
4:44pm Wed 29 Aug 12
firedog says...
5:47pm Wed 29 Aug 12
beyond the valley of the asbos says...
ct.co.uk?
6:17pm Wed 29 Aug 12
SoTyred says...
6:45pm Wed 29 Aug 12
southendshrimper says...
7:01pm Wed 29 Aug 12
Brunning999 says...
She will lose a claim, otherwise us local tax payers will be broke.
8:04pm Wed 29 Aug 12
Almeda11 says...
There are many areas, particularly along the most direct route, the London Rd, from Highlands in Leigh to Southend Victoria Plaza, but our short sighted council lacks the will to do this, it`s done in most of the continent with great successs, just what is wrong with this country?
8:12pm Wed 29 Aug 12
V_is_back says...
8:16pm Wed 29 Aug 12
Almeda11 says...
8:18pm Wed 29 Aug 12
Nebs says...
8:20pm Wed 29 Aug 12
V_is_back says...
http://bit.ly/NW5rNu
8:27pm Wed 29 Aug 12
Almeda11 says...
l said a single white line, or other indicator, grey, whatever.
THESE WORK WELL on the continent where l have travelled widely, particularly Germany and Holland, where they have more imagination and common sense.
ln Germany for example, when these tracks cross side streets, in some areas they even have their own small set of traffic lights, other areas the pavement is divided, 50/50 equally for pedestrians and cyclists.
There is no trouble, if a cyclist is coming up to a couple of pedestrians and needs to pass they just politely give a ring with their bell and people give them room to pass, there, unlike here unfortunately, they know the spirit of co-operation and it works well!
9:11pm Wed 29 Aug 12
V_is_back says...
9:29pm Wed 29 Aug 12
beyond the valley of the asbos says...
10:43pm Wed 29 Aug 12
Almeda11 says...
The difference between here and there is the approach.
There, they do have the dividing line and it works! people walk on the pedestrian part, and cyclists keep to the cyclying part.
Where the actual pavement is used by both, this is simply indicated by a sign every so often that shows a picture of a cyclist on one side and a pedestrian on the other, so that everyone knows it is for both, a bit like shared space, but strictly only for cyclists and pedestrians, this is the bit where, if 2 people are walking abreast and the cyclist wants to pass, they ring, and people move aside to let them, l`ve never seen any problems or unpleasantness, people just accept it and co operate with each other, l think we could learn some lessons here from that!!
When the cycle path is separate from the pavement then obviously it`s easier as the bounderies are completely separate.
10:48pm Wed 29 Aug 12
V_is_back says...
10:50pm Wed 29 Aug 12
jayman says...
as bad ideas go this one has knocked on the door several times while shouting "im a bad idea" been invited in, given a glass of council tax payer funded fine port, had a **** fuelled night with common senses wife, smoked a cigarette out of the packet of 20 ridiculous. and stuffed its cardigan with cash on its way out in the morning.
10:53pm Wed 29 Aug 12
jayman says...
12:01am Thu 30 Aug 12
Nebs says...
3:35am Thu 30 Aug 12
v.randy says...
Crossing the shared space with my children seems rather tedious as neither
the pedestrian (me) or the car driver actually knows precisely who has right of way.
Either I can just step out and bring the traffic to a halt (hopefully) or wait until a driver makes eye contact with me indicating that he will stop and allow me passage.
Either way NOT CLEAR and where ever there is doubt or confusion you will get problems.This is why the M.O.T has spent decades painting black and white strips on our roads at regular intervals in order to allow us safe passage..I think they are called 'zebra's'.
7:47am Thu 30 Aug 12
tatersalad says...
7:50am Thu 30 Aug 12
V_is_back says...
7:51am Thu 30 Aug 12
V_is_back says...
11:06am Thu 30 Aug 12
Nebs says...
1:24pm Thu 30 Aug 12
dotdot says...
1:59pm Thu 30 Aug 12
beyond the valley of the asbos says...
7:38pm Thu 30 Aug 12
EssexPerson says...
2:09am Fri 31 Aug 12
John the resonator says...
9:07am Fri 31 Aug 12
V_is_back says...
Marine Parade is not a shared space.
Southend council must either remove the kerbs and anything else that indicates a road, or they must stop calling it shared space.
10:47pm Fri 31 Aug 12
Almeda11 says...
But, it obviously makes more sense to have a decent, working setup as they do on the continent. Even though l cycle on the roads, l feel safer on the continent because of their cycle tracks or shared pavements, and l have had a couple of idiot drivers in Southend who just opened their car doors without checking, l actually carry a camera with me, for evidence, if l am ever hit, it`s useful, but as l keep saying it works well on the continent, it could work well here, it is only the will by the council, who think they always know best, and are always right, even when they are not, and that is something l do not respect!
10:58pm Fri 31 Aug 12
Almeda11 says...
9:19am Sat 1 Sep 12
V_is_back says...
Even better get yourself a helmet camera and save the video of close passes.
9:22am Sat 1 Sep 12
V_is_back says...
10:48am Sat 1 Sep 12
QuiteBored says...
2:32pm Sat 1 Sep 12
Cor Blimey says...
2:36pm Sat 1 Sep 12
Cor Blimey says...
10:01pm Sat 1 Sep 12
Last Poster says...
As for that woman on a bike, I might sue her for wasting space in my Echo!
8:42am Sun 2 Sep 12
Laong Laan says...
10:25pm Sun 2 Sep 12
Almeda11 says...
Re, the helmet with camera, l like that one, and will definately make enquiries, a good idea! thanks!