Drink-driving shame for ‘role model’ Shoeburyness High School teacher

A TEACHER’S career is hanging in the balance, after he crashed his car while more than three times over the alcohol limit.

James Birch, 54, narrowly avoided a jail sentence, when he appeared before Southend magistrates yesterday.

He has been suspended from his job, at Shoebury ness High School, pending a disciplinary hearing to decide his fate.

The court heard he had left the Plough & Sail pub, in London Road, Westcliff , and decided to drive the 250 yard journey home, in his Vauxhall Zafira.

Birch had reached his street, Ramuz Drive, when he collided with a parked Nissan pick-up truck, which then shunted into a Mercedes. He told police he thought he may have swerved to avoid an animal in the road.

A neighbour was at home in bed at about 10.45pm, on June 24, and heard a noise. When he realised it was a crash, he went out to see if anyone was injured.

It was then he saw Birch manoeuvring the car, so the neighbour removed the ignition keys and called the police.

Ian Allen, prosecuting, said: “It was apparent he had been drinking.”

Birch pleaded guilty to driving over the limit – with 131 microgrammes of alcohol in 100 millilitres of breath. The legal limit is 35microgrammes.

Micaila Williams, in mitigation, said Birch had been “bemused” by this high reading, as he only drank four pints of Carling. Any reading over 121microgrammes puts a defendant at risk of custody.

Miss Williams said her client realised his behaviour would have a negative impact, particularly as he teaches his pupils there are consequences to bad behaviour.

She added: “He is a role model for his own children and a role model for those at school. All of these things have been lost through his wrong doing.”

Birch sat with his head bowed, as the court heard he was remorseful, had no previous convictions, and two character references were handed to the magistrates.

He was sentenced to an eight week jail term, suspended for a year, three-year driving ban, 180 hours of unpaid work and £85 costs.

Miss Williams said he would now face a disciplinary hearing on September 19, which will decide whether he is fit to keep his job.

Comments(14)

Brunning999 says...
3:57pm Fri 10 Aug 12

Shame probably a good teacher but booze has got to him, like so many good people.

Tough decision making him unemployed will just add to hi problems.

A Cut the booze or lose you chose decision.

Audioman says...
4:03pm Fri 10 Aug 12

What's it got to do with the school???
If he was an MP he would still be an MP.
Let the poor man along for God's sake,
he has alife to lead the same as anyboby
else.

AndyBSG says...
4:08pm Fri 10 Aug 12

"Birch had been “bemused” by this high reading, as he only drank four pints of Carling"

To be fair, the obvious question would be how did he manage to become a teacher if this is the level of his intelligence, surely any fool knows that even one pint puts you over the limit unless it's a very weak lager!

Speedysnail says...
4:20pm Fri 10 Aug 12

So what if he loses his job. Anybody who drinks and drives deserve all they get. Not so much of a role model now!!!!!

Dangerous driver says...
4:23pm Fri 10 Aug 12

It was only 250 yards away, so to be honest, it was a bit stupid of him. A 5 minute walk maximum, the odd trip or slip, but im sure the guy would of made it home and well. Now his paying with a 3 year ban, plus the chance of no job. Jesus christ, drink driving is not worth it.

CALL ME CLINT says...
5:05pm Fri 10 Aug 12

Driving whilst over the limit for alcohol cannot be condoned.

The courts are the places where punishment should be handed down and not in a committee room of the education authority or whatever body is given the task of 'disciplining' teachers.

Why do we look to teachers to set an example to children in their (the teachers') private lives? The examples should be set by responsible parents.

I wish this man the best of luck with his future and hope that this one indiscretion (there is no evidence of past failings) can be put behind him and that he is given the opportunity to finish his career just as the vast majority of workers (with the exception of those specifically employed to drive) would be.

Let's face it, Hanningfield has been released early from custody and is allowed to get back to the den of thieves. Outrageous!

pussycats says...
5:16pm Fri 10 Aug 12

Well said Audioman.

jaguarxxv says...
6:49pm Fri 10 Aug 12

Plough & Sail??

Zena1398 says...
7:00pm Fri 10 Aug 12

Oh no! He was an amazing role model when I was at this school still an amazon guy everyone makes mistakes, he is an amazing teacher!! No matter what he has done!

bazaarhorse says...
7:34am Sat 11 Aug 12

Audioman wrote:
What's it got to do with the school???
If he was an MP he would still be an MP.
Let the poor man along for God's sake,
he has alife to lead the same as anyboby
else.
I agree apart from this 'God's sake' His sake surely.

girlie71 says...
11:11am Sun 12 Aug 12

what an expensive 250 yards ...

Spaldinho says...
10:04pm Sun 12 Aug 12

I am very disappointed with the level of sympathy and support being shown for him, and it's because he's a teacher. If a £500,000 a year banker did it in his Ferrari, people would be calling for him to be beheaded. The man broke the law and should be punished accordingly. There are some jobs that you will lose when you get your first criminal conviction, and this is a risk you take when you break the law. Each individual case should be taken as they are found and I hope the school can determine the best way forward.

Sean4u says...
11:16pm Sun 12 Aug 12

He lives so close to his place of work there should have been an earlier article starting "Driving shame". A hard way to learn to ride a bicycle or take a bus when you live that close to your regular destinations. Still - they say you're never too old to learn.

Get yourself a nice road bike (not a mountain bike, they're rubbish for commuting on) with a 'sit up and beg' riding position and granny gears for the inclines, plenty of high-vis clothes, carriers front and back and some nice big Ortleib panniers. Get a hub dynamo (not one of those aquaplaning tyre-scrubbers) and carry back-up lights for the winter. Don't try to save too much money, the miles are going to add up.

APR says...
9:38am Mon 13 Aug 12

I agree, nothing to do with the school.

He is still an idiot though.


.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree