CAMPAIGNERS say they are dubious about claims 21,000 jobs could be created through garden communities over the next 30 years.

The Centre for Economics and Business Research (CEBR) was commissioned to produce employment figures for north Essex authorities.

Proposed garden communities would be west of Braintree, West Tey and on the Tendring-Colchester border.

CEBR analysed population statistics and employment forecasts to estimate the number of jobs they could create.

Not including construction jobs, it is claimed 21,500 jobs would be created by 2050.

Most of the land would be allocated for offices, industrial and warehouse use, but there is no guarantee people living in the garden communities would choose to work there.

CEBR economist Robert Beauchamp said: “It’s still early planning so the question will come later on how to monitor it.

"We could work with employers to monitor residential locations of employees.

“We cannot force people to work in a location but we can put policies in place to encourage people to look for employment in their local area.

"The garden communities will provide employment space to give a competitive edge.”

Braintree, Colchester and Tendring councils have published further information following questions raised by a planning inspector last year showing an infrastructure-led approach is more viable.

But members of the Campaign Against Urban Sprawl in Essex (Cause) are not convinced.

Cause spokesman Rosie Pearson said: “It seems to be yet another case of hope triumphing over reality.

“Evidence will have to be scrutinised extremely carefully and the new employment study will have to explain why it contradicts the previous one.

“That one found to create one job per home for West Tey alone, there would need to be a step change in employment growth in Colchester, for example the building of a new hospital.”

The revised evidence will be considered by the councils’ Local Plan committees this month and then by full councils ahead of a consultation.